Choosing the best eye highlighter depends on your desired effect and routine. For a natural, lit-from-within radiance, the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator stands out for its subtle glow and skin-like finish. If you prefer quick, precise application with a creamy texture, the Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Highlighter Pencil in Champagne offers effortless brightness. For versatile, waterproof shimmer, the Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener provides multi-use glow that lasts all day. Lastly, for targeted inner corner and brow bone brightness, the tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight delivers a reliable, long-wearing pencil option. Each pick balances different tradeoffs—natural vs. intense, powder vs. cream, convenience vs. versatility—making your choice depend on your specific eye highlighting needs.
Get wellness gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- The LAURA GELLER Swirl Illuminator offers a natural, luminous glow suitable for all skin tones.
- Lune+Aster’s crayon provides easy, precise application with a vegan, gluten-free formula.
- Thrive’s cream-to-powder stick is versatile, waterproof, and nourishing but may be harder to blend for some.
- tarte’s waterproof pencil excels for long-lasting inner corner and brow bone brightness, ideal for contact lens wearers.
- Choosing between powder, cream, and pencil formats depends on your preferred application style and desired intensity.
| LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator, Gilded Honey |  | Best for Natural, All-Over Glow | Finish: Dewy, luminous | Format: Baked gel | Shade Range: Universal | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Highlighter Pencil Crayon, Silky Champagne |  | Best for Precision & Convenience | Shade: Champagne | Format: Crayon | Texture: Silky | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener Eyeshadow Stick Champagne Shine |  | Best for Multi-Use & Waterproof Shine | Finish: Shimmer | Formulation: Cream-to-powder | Waterproof: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight – Brightening Highlighter Pencil for Eyes & Brows |  | Best for Long-Lasting Brightening | Type: Highlighter Pencil | Vegan: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| eye highlighter | Finish | Format | Vegan | Waterproof |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Ge | Dewy, luminous | Baked gel | — | — |
| Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Hig | — | Crayon | Yes | — |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant E | Shimmer | — | — | Yes |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight | — | — | Yes | Yes |
More Details on Our Top Picks
LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator, Gilded Honey
This baked gelato swirl illuminator stands out for creating a subtle, luminous glow that melts into the skin, making it ideal for a lit-from-within effect. It’s suitable for all skin tones, thanks to its universal shade and natural finish. Compared with powder highlighters, this option offers a more skin-like, dewy look that lasts long without excessive shimmer. However, it requires proper application—using a dense brush or fingers—to avoid uneven blending. This pick makes the most sense for those seeking a glow that enhances rather than overpowers, especially if they prefer a more natural highlight over shimmer or glitter.
Pros:- Creates a natural, luminous glow
- Suitable for all skin tones
- Long-lasting, melts into skin
Cons:- Requires proper application for best results
Best for: People wanting a natural, everyday glow that works on all skin tones
Not ideal for: Users seeking a highly reflective or glittery highlighter, or those preferring powder textures
- Finish:Dewy, luminous
- Format:Baked gel
- Shade Range:Universal
- Longevity:All-day
- Skin Type:All
- Glitter/Shimmer:None
Our verdict“Ideal for those seeking a natural, long-lasting glow with a skin-like finish.”
Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Highlighter Pencil Crayon, Silky Champagne
This highlighter pencil offers a silky, easy-to-apply glow that’s perfect for quick touch-ups or on-the-go routines. Its crayon format eliminates the need for brushes or sharpener, making it a highly convenient choice. The Champagne shade adds a subtle, brightening effect to inner corners, brow bones, and other high points. Compared to powder or cream formulas, this crayon delivers a smooth, controlled application, but its limited shade options may restrict variety. It’s best suited for users who want a fuss-free, portable highlighter that adds just enough brightness without shimmer overload.
Pros:- Creates effortlessly illuminated eyes
- No sharpening needed, portable design
- Vegan, gluten-free, dermatologist tested
Cons:- Limited shade options
- May not satisfy those wanting powder highlighters
Best for: Individuals seeking quick, precise eye highlights with minimal fuss
Not ideal for: Those who prefer powder textures or a broad shade selection
- Shade:Champagne
- Format:Crayon
- Texture:Silky
- Vegan:Yes
- Gluten-Free:Yes
- Paraben-Free:Yes
- Dermatologist Tested:Yes
Our verdict“A perfect choice for users who prioritize convenience and a silky finish over extensive shade options.”
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener Eyeshadow Stick Champagne Shine
This cream-to-powder eyeshadow stick combines versatility with durability. It provides a soft, diffused glow that can be used on the eyes, brow bone, or even lips for a subtle highlight. Its nourishing oils help hydrate the skin, and the waterproof formula ensures all-day wear, even in humid conditions. Compared to simpler pencils, it’s more multi-purpose and offers a more substantial shimmer finish, but it can be tricky to blend for some users and requires sharpening. This option is excellent for those who want a multi-use product that withstands wear and tear, especially if they like a shimmer finish and don’t mind some extra application time.
Pros:- Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- Multi-use for eyes, cheeks, lips
- Infused with nourishing oils
Cons:- Difficult to blend for some users
- Limited to shimmer finish
- Requires sharpening
Best for: Active users who need a durable, multi-purpose highlighter with nourishing benefits
Not ideal for: Beginners or those preferring quick, no-fuss application or matte finishes
- Finish:Shimmer
- Formulation:Cream-to-powder
- Waterproof:Yes
- Usage:Eyes, brow bone, lips
- Nourishing Ingredients:Macadamia seed oil, Meadowfoam seed oil
- Built-in Sharpener:Yes
Our verdict“Best suited for active, multi-tasking users who want durability and hydration in their highlighter.”
tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight – Brightening Highlighter Pencil for Eyes & Brows
This vegan, cruelty-free highlighter pencil excels at brightening the inner corners, brow bone, and waterline with a smooth glide. Its waterproof, long-wear formula guarantees all-day brightness, making it a reliable choice for contact lens wearers or those needing a durable highlight. The built-in smudger adds convenience for blending, although it may require multiple layers for a really intense brightness. Compared to liquid or gel highlighters, this pencil offers a no-mess, fuss-free application that’s perfect for busy mornings. It’s especially suitable for those who want a dependable, brightening product that withstands humidity and tears.
Pros:- Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Smooth application with built-in smudger
Cons:- May require multiple layers for brightness
- Limited shade options
Best for: Users needing a long-lasting, waterproof pencil for inner corners and brow bones
Not ideal for: People seeking a powder or cream highlighter or a more intense shimmer
- Type:Highlighter Pencil
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Waterproof:Yes
- Duration:8 hours
- Ophthalmologist Tested:Yes
Our verdict“A solid choice for long-lasting brightness, particularly for inner corner and brow bone highlighting.”
How We Picked
Our selection process focused on a mix of user reviews, product versatility, formula quality, and overall value. We prioritized high-performing options that excel in specific roles—whether natural glow, precision highlighting, or all-day waterproof wear. Each product was evaluated for ease of use, skin compatibility, and finish, with a preference for formulas that suit a range of skin tones and preferences. Tradeoffs such as application convenience versus intensity or finish type were considered to ensure each pick offers a distinct advantage for different types of users.
| eye highlighter | Finish | Format |
|---|---|---|
| LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Ge | Dewy, luminous | Baked gel |
| Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Hig | — | Crayon |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant E | Shimmer | — |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Eye Highlighters
Choosing the right eye highlighter revolves around your preferred application method, desired finish, and specific use cases. Whether you want a subtle glow with a natural finish, a quick pop of brightness, or a long-lasting, waterproof shimmer, understanding these factors helps narrow your options. The key is to match the product’s formula and format to your routine and skin type for the best results.Finish and Effect
Decide if you want a subtle, natural glow or a more intense, shimmering highlight. Matte or dewy finishes are generally more natural, while shimmer or glitter adds more brightness and drama. The chosen finish impacts how the highlighter complements your overall makeup look and skin tone.
Application Format
Highlighters come in powders, creams, sticks, and pencils. Powders are versatile and easy to blend, ideal for a diffused glow. Creams and sticks tend to offer a more hydrating, luminous finish and can be easier to work with for targeted highlighting. Pencils are perfect for quick, precise application, especially in inner corners or brow bones.
Longevity and Water Resistance
If you need a highlighter that lasts all day or withstands humidity, look for waterproof or long-wear formulas. These are especially useful for special events or humid climates. Keep in mind that waterproof products often require more effort to blend and remove.
Skin Compatibility and Shade Range
Check if the product is suitable for your skin type and tone. Vegan, cruelty-free, and dermatologist-tested options tend to be gentler and better suited for sensitive skin. Shade variety ensures you can find a highlighter that complements your natural skin tone, whether you prefer a subtle sheen or a more noticeable glow.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best type of highlighter for a natural glow?
The baked gelato swirl illuminator like the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Gilded Honey offers a luminous, natural finish that melts into the skin, making it ideal for a subtle, everyday glow. Powder and cream formulas with a dewy finish are also excellent choices for a natural look.
Are pencil highlighters suitable for all skin types?
Yes, pencil highlighters like the tarte Fake Awake are generally suitable for all skin types, especially because they are easy to apply and blend. Their compact, precise format makes them perfect for quick touch-ups and targeted highlighting without mess or fuss.
Which highlighter is best for long-lasting wear?
The tarte Fake Awake Highlighter Pencil is designed for all-day waterproof wear, making it an excellent choice for lasting brightness, especially for busy or humid days. The Thrive Causemetics stick also offers waterproof, long-lasting performance but may require more effort to blend seamlessly.
Can I use highlighters on my lips or cheeks?
Some highlighters like the Thrive Causemetics stick are formulated for multiple uses, including lips and cheeks, providing a cohesive glow across your face. However, most eye highlighters are designed specifically for the delicate eye area, so check product labels before using on lips or cheeks.
What should I consider if I have sensitive skin?
Look for highlighters that are dermatologist tested, vegan, and free from common irritants like parabens or phthalates. The Lune+Aster crayon, for example, is vegan and dermatologist tested, making it a safer choice for sensitive skin.
Conclusion
Select your eye highlighter based on your routine and preferences. If you favor a natural, everyday glow, the LAURA GELLER baked gelato is a perfect pick. For quick, precise application on the go, the Lune+Aster crayon offers convenience. Those needing durability and multi-use options should consider the Thrive stick, especially if waterproof performance is important. Finally, contact lens wearers or anyone needing a dependable brightening in specific eye areas will find the tarte pencil a reliable choice. Each product shines in its niche, so your ideal pick depends on your specific highlighting needs and lifestyle.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
